EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES

Fincast vs. LendingTree: How to Shop Smarter for Your Mortgag

Benjamin Schieken, Fincast founder and mortgage loan originator, providing mortgage transparency tools and loan comparison guidance for confident homebuyer decisions

Written by

Benjamin Schieken

Shopping for a mortgage means you'll encounter many comparison platforms. Two that often get confused are Fincast and LendingTree.

Both involve connecting borrowers with multiple lenders, but they serve different purposes. Fincast is a reverse auction platform where vetted lenders compete based on your actual Loan Estimate. LendingTree is a lead generation service that matches you with multiple lenders who may contact you.

Understanding both helps you choose the right comparison approach for your situation.

Key Takeaways

Fincast:

A reverse auction platform where you upload one Loan Estimate, and vetted lenders compare your offer to what they can provide—potentially leading to more competitive terms through direct, transparent competition without duplicate applications.

LendingTree:

A lead generation and matching service founded in 1996 that connects your information with multiple lenders in an open marketplace, who may then contact you with separate offers.

Biggest Difference:

Fincast = active lender competition based on actual offers.

LendingTree = passive lead distribution with varied responses.

💡 Pro Tip: Use LendingTree to gather initial quotes, then upload your Loan Estimate to Fincast to see if vetted lenders can beat it through direct competition—without more phone calls or applications.

What Is Fincast?

Fincast is a reverse-auction platform where pre-screened, licensed lenders evaluate your actual Loan Estimate and may present more competitive terms. You upload your Loan Estimate once, and lenders compete without completing new applications or unsolicited contact.

Fincast creates active competition by letting you upload an existing Loan Estimate, then showing:

  • Which vetted lenders have more competitive offers

  • Direct comparison of rates and fees side-by-side

Unlike filling out forms that distribute your information, Fincast requires a single upload of your existing Loan Estimate. Lenders compete to offer more competitive terms, and you control the process. Lenders never receive your full contact details unless you choose to engage with them.

Plus, Fincast only works with licensed, pre-screened lenders who agree to transparent terms. There are never any spam calls or unsolicited contacts.

👉 Think of Fincast as eBay for mortgages—lenders may present more competitive terms to earn your business.

What Is LendingTree?

LendingTree is a lead-generation and matching service that connects borrowers with multiple lenders through an open marketplace.

Founded in 1996, LendingTree is one of the longest-running mortgage lead marketplaces.

The LendingTree experience includes:

  • Form-based application with personal and financial information

  • Distribution of your lead to multiple lenders

  • Phone calls and emails from interested lenders

  • Separate applications with each lender who responds

  • Open marketplace with varying lender quality

LendingTree offers broad lender access, appealing to borrowers who want to cast a wide net and are comfortable managing multiple contacts.

Fincast vs. LendingTree: Side-by-Side

Feature

Fincast

LendingTree

When You Use It

After you have a Loan Estimate to benchmark

When starting your lender search

Purpose

Create active lender competition to potentially  offer more competitive terms

Get matched with multiple lenders who may contact you

Accuracy

Lenders compete based on actual Loan Estimate terms

Lenders respond with separate offers if interested

Best For

Borrowers who want competing offers from vetted lenders

Borrowers starting from scratch who don't mind calls

How Should I Use Both When Buying a Home?

Both platforms play different roles—one helps you generate initial leads, the other helps you compete for them.

Step 1: Start Your Search

Start your search using LendingTree to get matched with multiple lenders. Complete their form to receive initial contact from interested lenders.

Step 2: Apply and Get a Loan Estimate

Choose the most promising lender from LendingTree (or any lender you trust) and complete a full application. Within three business days, you'll receive a Loan Estimate.

Step 3: Upload Your Loan Estimate to Fincast

Upload your Loan Estimate to Fincast. The platform creates a reverse auction in which vetted lenders can compete to offer more competitive terms—without duplicate applications.

Step 4: Compare Offers

Review which lenders may offer more competitive terms than your LendingTree-sourced offer through Fincast's active competition—no more phone calls or lead distribution required.

Step 5: Choose and Lock Your Rate

If your original lender has more attractive terms, proceed with confidence. If Fincast surfaces a better competing offer, switch before closing. Then lock your rate to protect against market changes.

Why Active Competition Matters

Lead generation platforms like LendingTree connect you with lenders, but they don't create direct competition. Each lender operates independently, unaware of competing offers.

A reverse auction like Fincast creates transparency through active competition. The key difference: lenders see what they need to beat.

With LendingTree, you might receive five separate offers, each requiring an application and phone calls. With Fincast, lenders compete based on your existing offer—you control the process without the spam.

Compare Offers Effortlessly Using Fincast

Comparing mortgage offers doesn't require managing multiple lender contacts. Use Fincast to create a reverse auction in which vetted lenders submit competing offers.

Upload your Loan Estimate once—Fincast creates competition among vetted lenders.

You get the benefits of competition without the headaches of lead distribution and multiple lender contacts.

FAQs

1. Is Fincast the same as LendingTree?

No. Fincast is a reverse-auction platform where lenders compete based on actual offers; LendingTree is a lead-generation service that distributes your information to multiple lenders.

2. When should I use Fincast?

Once you have a Loan Estimate from any source (including lenders found through LendingTree), upload it to Fincast to get competitive offers.

3. Will I get spam calls with Fincast?

No. Unlike lead generation services, Fincast doesn't distribute your contact information. Lenders compete for your business based on your Loan Estimate, without unsolicited contact.

4. Does Fincast work with LendingTree lenders?

Fincast benchmarks your offer regardless of source. If you found a lender through LendingTree, upload that Loan Estimate to see if vetted lenders can provide a more competitive offer.

5. How does Fincast differ from lead generation?

Fincast creates active competition based on actual terms. Lead generation distributes your information for passive responses without direct competition.

Bottom Line

With Fincast, you can shop for competitive rates and terms with confidence—all without spam calls or the need to reapply to multiple lenders.

Pro Tips (Save These!)

  • Use LendingTree to generate initial leads, then use Fincast to identify competitors.

  • Upload any Loan Estimate to Fincast—even from lenders you found through lead generation services.

  • Use Fincast to benchmark any lender's offer with vetted lenders through a reverse auction.

Action Checklist

  • Get matched with lenders through LendingTree (or apply directly anywhere)

  • Complete the application and receive your Loan Estimate

  • Upload your Loan Estimate to Fincast to create a reverse auction

  • Review competing offers from vetted lenders

  • Choose the best deal and lock your rate

👉 Ready to create active competition? Upload your Loan Estimate to Fincast and see if vetted lenders can offer more competitive terms.



Disclaimer: Nothing in this content should be considered financial advice. The examples and data shared are for general information only and may not reflect your personal situation. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. Always do your own research and speak with a qualified financial advisor before making any financial decisions.

Ready to Save On Your New Mortgage?

3D house with dollar savings, percentage sign, and hourglass icons representing mortgage savings and quick closing with Fincast

Unlock the best rates while saving time and money

Smart homeowners are discovering better mortgage deals with Fincast's secure, AI-powered platform

Find a better deal

Fincast logo with stylized ‘F’ emphasizing speed and modern financial services

Upload Loan Estimate

NEWSLETTER

The Fincast Brief

Sign up for our weekly newsletter for tips to make homeownership more affordable and enjoyable — trusted by thousands of Americans.

Fincast, Inc. is a digital shopping technology and online marketplace with its main business address located at 66 West Flagler Street, 9th Floor, Miami, FL 33130, Telephone Number (866) 986-1680. Fincast, Inc. provides administrative and marketplace services by matching consumers, who are prospective borrowers, with one or more banks, brokers, and/or lenders (each a "Lender"). Fincast, Inc. may also connect consumers with relevant Settlement Companies and/or Insurers that offer products and/or services of interest. Fincast, Inc. is not a Lender, Settlement Company, or Insurer and does not: originate, underwrite, make or refinance loans; make credit decisions in connection with loans or insurance policies; issue loan commitments or lock-in agreements; or guarantee that your submission of information on the Site will result in the origination or refinancing of a loan from a Lender, a policy from an Insurer; or guarantee a better deal or economic benefit of any kind.

Fincast, Inc. does not include information about every financial or credit product or service.Fincast, Inc. calculates and discloses averages based on comparisons of Loan Estimates presented along with data compiled from consumers and companies. Fincast, Inc. does not guarantee these claims or complete accuracy of these figures, as they are constantly changing and are estimated at a particular moment in time. Fincast, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of the information provided by lenders in our bidding platform and Fincast cannot be held liable for any deal detail discrepancies or miscalculations. These offers and deals are not guaranteed and are subject to change.

Fincast, Inc. NMLS Consumer Access #2496069 MORTGAGE BROKER ONLY, NOT A MORTGAGE LENDER OR MORTGAGE CORRESPONDENT LENDER.

This site is directed at, and made available to, persons in Colorado, Texas, and Florida only.

© 2025 Fincast, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Fincast, Inc. is a digital shopping technology and online marketplace with its main business address located at 66 West Flagler Street, 9th Floor, Miami, FL 33130, Telephone Number (866) 986-1680. Fincast, Inc. provides administrative and marketplace services by matching consumers, who are prospective borrowers, with one or more banks, brokers, and/or lenders (each a "Lender"). Fincast, Inc. may also connect consumers with relevant Settlement Companies and/or Insurers that offer products and/or services of interest. Fincast, Inc. is not a Lender, Settlement Company, or Insurer and does not: originate, underwrite, make or refinance loans; make credit decisions in connection with loans or insurance policies; issue loan commitments or lock-in agreements; or guarantee that your submission of information on the Site will result in the origination or refinancing of a loan from a Lender, a policy from an Insurer; or guarantee a better deal or economic benefit of any kind.

Fincast, Inc. does not include information about every financial or credit product or service.Fincast, Inc. calculates and discloses averages based on comparisons of Loan Estimates presented along with data compiled from consumers and companies. Fincast, Inc. does not guarantee these claims or complete accuracy of these figures, as they are constantly changing and are estimated at a particular moment in time. Fincast, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of the information provided by lenders in our bidding platform and Fincast cannot be held liable for any deal detail discrepancies or miscalculations. These offers and deals are not guaranteed and are subject to change.

Fincast, Inc. NMLS Consumer Access #2496069 MORTGAGE BROKER ONLY, NOT A MORTGAGE LENDER OR MORTGAGE CORRESPONDENT LENDER.

This site is directed at, and made available to, persons in Colorado, Texas, and Florida only.

© 2025 Fincast, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Fincast, Inc. is a digital shopping technology and online marketplace with its main business address located at 66 West Flagler Street, 9th Floor, Miami, FL 33130, Telephone Number (866) 986-1680. Fincast, Inc. provides administrative and marketplace services by matching consumers, who are prospective borrowers, with one or more banks, brokers, and/or lenders (each a "Lender"). Fincast, Inc. may also connect consumers with relevant Settlement Companies and/or Insurers that offer products and/or services of interest. Fincast, Inc. is not a Lender, Settlement Company, or Insurer and does not: originate, underwrite, make or refinance loans; make credit decisions in connection with loans or insurance policies; issue loan commitments or lock-in agreements; or guarantee that your submission of information on the Site will result in the origination or refinancing of a loan from a Lender, a policy from an Insurer; or guarantee a better deal or economic benefit of any kind.

Fincast, Inc. does not include information about every financial or credit product or service.Fincast, Inc. calculates and discloses averages based on comparisons of Loan Estimates presented along with data compiled from consumers and companies. Fincast, Inc. does not guarantee these claims or complete accuracy of these figures, as they are constantly changing and are estimated at a particular moment in time. Fincast, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of the information provided by lenders in our bidding platform and Fincast cannot be held liable for any deal detail discrepancies or miscalculations. These offers and deals are not guaranteed and are subject to change.

Fincast, Inc. NMLS Consumer Access #2496069 MORTGAGE BROKER ONLY, NOT A MORTGAGE LENDER OR MORTGAGE CORRESPONDENT LENDER.

This site is directed at, and made available to, persons in Colorado, Texas, and Florida only.

© 2025 Fincast, Inc. All Rights Reserved